NHL 25 Review: A Fresh Start for the Franchise
EA Sports has taken a bold step by releasing NHL 25 exclusively for current-generation consoles, leaving behind previous-gen versions. This transition has opened the door to much-needed changes and improvements in the series. NHL 25 introduces several features that distinguish it from its predecessors, most notably ICE-Q and an overhauled Franchise Mode. The gameplay experience is notably more fluid, thanks to the developers’ focus on creating a smoother and more engaging hockey experience. There were moments throughout gameplay where it genuinely felt like “That was some darn good hockey.”
Intelligent Hockey: ICE-Q Technology
At the heart of NHL 25 is ICE-Q, a groundbreaking technology that enhances gameplay with true hockey intelligence through a new logic-driven animation system. ICE-Q comprises three key components, starting with Next-Gen Vision Control. Building on the pressure system from NHL 24, this feature allows players to better position themselves against puck carriers in scoring zones. The improvement in responsiveness translates to more scoring opportunities, although it complicates play behind the net.
The Skill Based One-Timers feature is another noteworthy addition, requiring players to set up their teammates effectively to execute a one-timer. The mechanic becomes visible with a gray indicator, which turns green upon a successful shot or red when missed. This system encourages teamwork without guaranteeing a goal, adding depth to offensive strategies.
The remaining components of ICE-Q—Empowered AI and Reactive Actions—significantly enhance the game’s AI, resulting in smoother gameplay flow. Gone are the days of AI collisions; players now demonstrate better positioning and reaction times. The revamped playbook contributes to more authentic gameplay as players rotate and position themselves effectively during plays.
The Best Playing Game Yet
NHL 25 delivers an impressively fluid experience over the course of a game, distinguishing itself from recent entries. While the development team has slowed the gameplay down, the integration of ICE-Q and AI improvements allows players to focus on hockey rather than fighting against the game mechanics. Players are encouraged to grind for positional advantages, leading to a satisfying scoring experience. Notably, the frequency of penalties has decreased, although this may require some tuning.
The AI goalie performance feels balanced, with notable saves during one-on-one scenarios, making scoring challenging but rewarding. This AI change enhances the sense of player agency, as it no longer feels like goals are merely gifts from the game.
Franchise Mode & Grudge Matches
Franchise Mode receives its most significant update in years. Players can now start as expansion teams, a unique feature in sports gaming. The new Franchise Hub consolidates all league information into a single screen, showcasing scores, stats, and player career information.
The introduction of a conversation system impacts team morale and dynamics, allowing for long-term and short-term goal setting for players. The new Grudge Match system adds an exciting element to rivalry games, offering boosts to top players and dynamic presentation changes that increase the stakes.
Additional Modes and Features
Hockey Ultimate Team now includes a Wildcard Mode, allowing for strategic drafting with salary cap considerations. This change encourages thoughtful team-building and adds a new layer to competition, both online and offline.
The return of World of Chel maintains its focus on player upgrades and attire, although it lacks substantial changes. The game continues to support various NHL teams, including the newly added Utah Hockey Club, while offering diverse league options.
Moving to Current Generation
With a focus on current-gen capabilities, NHL 25 features impressive visual enhancements, thanks to Sapien Technology, which accurately models player sizes and animations. Player movement appears more fluid, with jerseys flowing naturally and improved ice effects. While the lighting and ice details are striking, the crowd and coach models could use refinement.
Despite the presentation improvements, the overall experience still feels rushed. A more broadcast-style presentation with multiple commentary teams, similar to other EA Sports titles, would enhance immersion.
Closing Thoughts
NHL 25 marks a triumphant return to form for the franchise, revitalizing the series with meaningful gameplay changes and an enhanced Franchise Mode. The integration of ICE-Q and the AI enhancements ensure a more engaging experience, while the Grudge Match feature adds depth to rivalries. Though legacy issues like passing mechanics and presentation persist, the move to current-generation consoles has allowed EA Sports to deliver a significantly upgraded hockey experience. NHL 25 not only resonates with long-time fans but also sets a solid foundation for the future of the series.
